There have been a number of recent appeal decisions from the Upper Tribunal dealing with the issue of ‘reasonableness’ when considering whether an eviction order should be granted.
In one decision, Sheriff Collins, KC, in a case where the tenant had put forward no “defence” emphasised that the granting of an eviction order is still a matter for the Tribunal’s discretion. Obtaining an order is not ‘automatic’ even in an undefended case.
He stated that “The question of whether it is reasonable or not